TL;DR
Get coffee and tea gear delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
A video posted Aug. 17 by bartender and content creator Saeed “Hawk” House featured Kate Gerwin criticizing guest shifts she said can serve awards-chasing bars, alienate regulars and divert brand money from staff retention. The post drew far more views and comments than House’s typical videos, while reactions included support and accusations of hypocrisy. Gerwin says her criticism is aimed at some events’ purposes, not guest shifts as a whole.
A video criticizing some bartender guest shifts has sparked a debate across the bar community after Los Angeles-based creator Saeed “Hawk” House posted an interview with bartender and bar owner Kate Gerwin on Aug. 17. Gerwin argued that certain events prioritize awards and industry networking over workers and regular customers; the post drew substantially more engagement than other videos in House’s series and also prompted accusations of hypocrisy because Gerwin has taken part in guest shifts herself.
In the nearly three-minute video for House’s Instagram series Hospitality Hot Takes, Gerwin opened with the blunt line, “No one cares about your f*cking guest shift.” She said some events are staged to help bars pursue awards and give visiting bartenders a chance to socialize, while alienating regular customers. She also criticized brands for funding events instead of directing more money toward staff retention. At one point, she said, “I wanna see ‘em go away.”
VinePair reported that the post had reached 285,000 views, 12,200 likes and 782 comments as of its article. House said those were the highest figures for any post in the series. He told VinePair that the videos typically receive around 13,000 views per day, while his most popular posts generally earn 1,000 to 2,000 likes and 100 to 200 comments. The article did not specify the post’s total age when those numbers were recorded.
Responses were divided. Some commenters backed Gerwin’s criticism; others challenged it on the grounds that she has participated in guest shifts around the world. Gerwin acknowledged that her own experience makes her vulnerable to that charge. She said she is criticizing the purposes behind some prominent events, rather than rejecting every guest shift.
The Debate Over Guest-Shift Priorities
The argument reaches beyond whether bartenders enjoy visiting other bars. Guest shifts can involve brand sponsorship, industry networking and award ambitions, and Gerwin’s claims raise questions about who benefits when bars devote time and money to such events. Her account of the costs to regular customers and staff is her assessment; the source material does not independently establish how widespread those effects are.
The video’s reach also shows how a short, pointed social-media interview can bring an existing industry disagreement into public view. House told VinePair he expected the conversation to be provocative, but said he was not prepared for the response. The discussion includes both the substance of Gerwin’s claims and whether her own participation undermines them.
professional bartender cocktail shaker set
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Gerwin’s Experience and Awards Criticism
Gerwin owns Happy Accidents in Albuquerque and was described by VinePair as preparing to open Bad Apple in Houston. She has taken part in guest shifts internationally. She argued that this experience gives her a view of how events operate, while also recognizing that she has benefited from them and may lose opportunities by speaking against some practices.
Her sharpest criticism concerns events she says are designed to attract the attention of people connected to The 50, the awards group formerly known as World’s 50 Best. Gerwin alleged that some bars host shifts to cultivate favor with voters and said she had attended shifts where a voter was present. Those are her claims; the supplied report does not independently verify bars’ motives or establish that the awards process is pay-for-play.
House said the identity of the interviewee helped explain the post’s reach: Gerwin had participated in many guest shifts, making the criticism more pointed to viewers. Gerwin offered a different interpretation, suggesting that gender may have shaped the response. She said a similar comment from a man would not have attracted the same attention, citing a male industry figure’s public criticism of World’s 50 Best the previous year. The report provides no independent comparison of audience reactions to substantiate either explanation.
““The moment I filmed it, I knew it was going to be a little hot. But I wasn’t prepared for what was to come after it was posted.””
— Saeed “Hawk” House, speaking to VinePair
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
The Reach of the Allegations
The supplied report does not establish how common the practices Gerwin criticized are, whether specific bars held events to influence award voters, or whether brand sponsorship displaced spending on staff. Her claims about the awards ecosystem and voter attendance remain attributed allegations, not independently verified findings. The article also does not provide a response from The 50, the brands, or the bars implicated in her account.
It is also unclear how much of the reaction focused on the substance of her argument, her blunt wording, her own history of guest shifts, or the gender dynamics she described. Engagement totals are a snapshot reported by VinePair, not evidence that viewers agreed with her. Gerwin said she had not fully watched the finished video and thought the fast reactions to hot takes might have obscured her central point.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Whether the Industry Changes Course
At the time of VinePair’s report, the immediate development was the ongoing social-media debate; the source did not identify a formal response or policy change from awards organizers, sponsors or bars. The next indicators would be whether industry figures address Gerwin’s specific claims, whether bars change how they fund or organize guest shifts, and whether more discussion focuses on workers and local customers rather than awards exposure.
Gerwin said she hoped that, as the initial reaction cooled, the underlying point would become clearer: she does not oppose every guest shift, but objects to some events and the incentives behind them. No timeline or further action was confirmed in the report.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Key Questions
What did Kate Gerwin say about guest shifts?
In House’s Instagram interview, Gerwin criticized some guest shifts as serving award ambitions and social networking, while potentially alienating regular customers. She also argued that brands could direct money spent on events toward staff retention. She later clarified that she does not oppose every guest shift.
Why did the video attract unusually high engagement?
VinePair reported 285,000 views, 12,200 likes and 782 comments at the time of its article, the highest figures for House’s series. House said Gerwin’s history of guest shifts made her criticism especially provocative. Gerwin suggested gender could also have shaped the reaction; neither explanation was independently established.
Was Gerwin accused of hypocrisy?
Yes. Some responses pointed to her participation in guest shifts around the world. Gerwin acknowledged that history and said she has benefited from the events, but argued it also gives her experience with the practices she criticizes.
Did the report prove that guest shifts influence awards voting?
No. Gerwin alleged that some bars use events to gain favor with people connected to The 50 and described seeing voters at shifts. The report did not independently verify those claims or establish that the awards process is pay-for-play.
Does Gerwin want all guest shifts to end?
No. Although the video included the line “I wanna see ‘em go away,” Gerwin told VinePair that her objection is to the purpose behind some prominent events, not to guest shifts as a whole.
Source: rss
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
